Personally I am a bit skeptical about these experiments. Sure they MIGHT work for simple decisions, but this probably isn’t the case for more complex decisions that aren’t arbitrary and silly. And I’m pretty convinced that there technically is no free will and that we live in a deterministic universe, but in every day life it seems self-evident that we do have free will!
Tuesday, September 25, 2012
Most AMAZING fMRI Study!
The most interesting fMRI studying I’ve stumbled upon has to do with the idea of free will. While originally a famous EEG study, in recent years it has been ‘replicated’ in fMRI studies. Basically the essence of the study is something like researchers can detect what your arbitrary “A or B” choice is going to before you consciously make that decision. This has wide ranging impacts in the field of philosophy and the debates over free will. If when we think we “consciously make” a decision, is actually caused by our subconscious brain that we don’t have conscious control over, then that’s a powerful argument against free will.
Personally I am a bit skeptical about these experiments. Sure they MIGHT work for simple decisions, but this probably isn’t the case for more complex decisions that aren’t arbitrary and silly. And I’m pretty convinced that there technically is no free will and that we live in a deterministic universe, but in every day life it seems self-evident that we do have free will!
Personally I am a bit skeptical about these experiments. Sure they MIGHT work for simple decisions, but this probably isn’t the case for more complex decisions that aren’t arbitrary and silly. And I’m pretty convinced that there technically is no free will and that we live in a deterministic universe, but in every day life it seems self-evident that we do have free will!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hey Eddie! This is really interesting because I had no idea researchers were able to formulate some kind of study to attempt to quantify free will in the brain. I'm on the optimistic side of the free will argument- I'd like to think that free will does exist, but then again I haven't really thought about it much. Awesome post!
ReplyDelete